Urban A Review of The Family Crucible The Family Crucible, by Napier and Whitakerreads like a novel while at the same time laying down some of the fundamental concepts of family systems therapy. It is a case study of one family's experience in family therapy. While the therapy shifts from daughter to son and then to parent interaction to daughters and son, it is finally the couple's marriage that must be treated if issues are to be resolved. Even the grandparents are brought into therapy to get at the family of origin issues.
I understand more succinctly now, about the role our families of origin play out through our lives and how helpful it can be to acknowledge and bring to light those ways- some more damaging than others. Jun 03, Carter rated it liked it I have to agree with my professor, this book should be required reading for anyone thinking of working with families.
There are also chapters throughout that explain different aspects and theoretical information about working with families because it does present a very different dynamic.
The philosophy and methods of family therapy are revealed in an in-depth case study of a family whose daughter's deep depression resulted from her parents' troubled marriage3/5(5). Study The Family Crucible discussion and chapter questions and find The Family Crucible study guide questions and answers. The Family Crucible, by Napier and Whitaker (), reads like a novel while at the same time laying down some of the fundamental concepts of family systems therapy. It is a case study of one family's experience in family therapy.
And, most importantly, it shows that the counselors are human. They struggle with their own emotions and counter-transference.
I have to agree with my professor, this book should be required reading for anyone thinking of working with families.
That is even more significant when you consider these are professionals with years of experience. The family presented in the book is also a "typical" family with common problems, which makes the content more widely applicable.
I appreciated that throughout the text Napier takes breaks from the family sessions to go more in depth about specific problems, such as divorce or infidelity, and expand upon them from a clinical perspective.
In some circumstances it is a "do not do as I do, but learn from my example" scenario. If you are considering a career in the social sciences, especially family therapy, then read this book!
That seems like an excellent way to get sued and lose a therapy license in my book. Also, I found the author to be quite sexist, which may be appropriate for the time, but was off-putting. He never mentioned any of these things about the men. Here and there, I found some helpful gems of wisdom that I felt continued to hold true, but mostly, I felt the book was outdated and rather bizarre.
No more does this problem present consistently than in the realm of psychotherapy. Nevertheless, skepticism and doubt may be viewed as beneficial reactions to any assertion presented without significant and necessary research. Additionally, the issue of methods in research, and the intense inevitability of quantifiable metrics may result in either an over-mechanization or However thoroughly ideas and theory are presented, there is bound to be questionable doubt about their efficacy in practice.
Additionally, the issue of methods in research, and the intense inevitability of quantifiable metrics may result in either an over-mechanization or an under-appreciation of the complexity involved within the theoretical realm. Such is the case with this tremendously valuable text. Originally published inthe text is robust in experiential language yet lacking in quantitative verification.
Regardless, the techniques and methods utilized and explained throughout the example of a family case study are richly humanistic and detailed exemplars of the complex quality of the therapeutic encounter.
Whereas individual therapy may be appropriate for the person who wants to be comfortable with themselves, family therapy — as expressed throughout the text — serves the function of supporting the individual in learning to live with others. Hence, before a person can be ready for the psychological change required in individual therapy, they may first need to be unshackled from the controlling mechanism accentuated by the symbiotic family milieu.
In initially approaching this text, I will readily acknowledge that I place a passionate emphasis on individuality and the freedom of choice. Notwithstanding this comportment, I remained open to the approach through which the experiential attitude to family counseling magnifies the position of the individual in their lived world.
Whereas freedom autonomy and choice responsibilityin my opinion, are extremely essential aspects of the counseling process, I detected that I may have overlooked the important function that the family serves in constructing and sustaining the structures through which the individual has become themselves.
Therefore, uncovering the structure, the tone, and the patterns involved in the family system, may be more significant than the resultant problem presenting in the individual.THE FAMILY CRUCIBLE: Character List THERAPISTS Augustus "Gus" Napier Carl Whitaker THE BRICE FAMILY David (Father) Carolyn (Mother) Claudia (Oldest child-adolescence).
The Family Crucible - Augustus Napier, PhD and Carl Whitaker, MD by Melissa Hudson | This newsletter was created with Smore, an online tool for creating beautiful newsletters for for educators, nonprofits, businesses and more.
The Family Crucible: The Intense Experience of Family Therapy by Augustus Y. Napier PhD, Carl A. Whitaker M.D. The classic groundbreaking book on family therapy by acclaimed experts Augustus Y. Napier, Ph.D., and Carl Whitaker, M.D.5/5(5). Dec 01, · In The Family Crucible, the story and information presented is anything but sleepy.
I never would have chosen this book on my own, but am certainly glad it was assigned for my couples and family counseling course this term.
I was drawn into the Brice family from the first page and had difficulty putting the book down/5. The philosophy and methods of family therapy are revealed in an in-depth case study of a family whose daughter's deep depression resulted from her parents' troubled marriage3/5(5). He now directs The Family Workshop, a family therapy training institute in Atlanta, Georgia, where he works frequently with his wife, Margaret, who is also a family therapist.
A frequent consultant, he is the author of numerous papers and of The Fragile Bond, published by Harper & Row in /5(5).